UNHRC should act on Zimbabwe - expelled rights expert

  • World
  • Thursday, 29 Oct 2009

JOHANNESBURG/HARARE (Reuters) - United Nations torture expert Manfred Nowak said on Thursday he would recommend that the U.N. Human Rights Council (UNHRC) take action against Zimbabwe after his expulsion from the country.

Zimbabwean officials denied him entry and forced him to board a South Africa-bound plane on Thursday after he was detained by security officials on arrival overnight

Nowak, the UNHRC' special rapporteur on torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, told reporters after arriving in South Africa that his mission had failed.

"I think that it is the end of the mission. I think I have not been treated by any government in such a rude manner than by the government of Zimbabwe. I will not (go) back," Nowak said.

Nowak said he remained concerned about torture in Zimbabwe and would recommend that the UNHRC take action against the country.

"I will report to the Human Rights Council and I will recommend to them to take necessary action in respect of Zimbabwe."

Nowak did not say what action the council might take against Zimbabwe.

He said he had been invited to Zimbabwe by Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai, whose power-sharing deal with President Robert Mugabe is under severe strain.

"I think it sheds light on the present power structure of the unity government if the prime minister invites me for a personal meeting and his office is not in a position to clear my entrance to the country. That is a very alarming signal about the power structure of the present government."


The refusal to allow him entry to Zimbabwe was either a misunderstanding or something more deliberate on the part of some members of Mugabe's ZANU-PF party.

"There was a lot of either miscommunication, or it was a clear strategy by certain sections within the ZANU-PF, including of course the minister of foreign affairs, who just wanted to deny me entry and to deprive me of the possibility of assessing the human rights situation in the country," he told Reuters.

Tsvangirai's Movement for Democratic Change (MDC) has stopped cooperation with ZANU-PF in the unity government.

Zimbabwe's state-owned Herald newspaper accused Nowak of trying to "gatecrash into the country".

The newspaper said Nowak had been informed by the government that he could not visit because the country was hosting foreign ministers from the Southern African Development Community.

Officials from SADC, a regional grouping, opened talks on Thursday with the rival Zimbabwean parties in a bid to patch up the rift threatening the power-sharing government.

"The SADC delegation has already started the engagement process, with the ministers and officials talking to the different parties, laying the groundwork for consultations with the principal leaders," one SADC official told Reuters.

"We are not going to be playing this in the gallery because that is not constructive or the way to conduct a review or to mediate in any dispute," said the official who declined to be named or to discuss his team's chances of success.

Mugabe, who has led Zimbabwe since independence in 1980, formed a power-sharing government with Tsvangirai to end months of feuding in the impoverished country.

But Tsvangirai said two weeks ago he was boycotting the arrangement until problems had been resolved.

Nowak's invitation marked the first time Zimbabwe had offered to open up to an expert working for the UNHRC.

The urgency of an objective fact-finding by an independent U.N. expert was highlighted by allegations of the arrest, intimidation and harassment of MDC supporters and of human rights defenders in the past few days, the U.N. said.

(Additional reporting by Cris Chinaka in Harare and Serena Chaudhry in Johannesburg; Writing by Marius Bosch; Editing by Giles Elgood)

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3

Did you find this article insightful?


Across the site