Legal experts call for immediate Sosma reforms


PETALING JAYA: Legal experts have urged the government to immediately implement the Par­lia­mentary Special Select Commit­tee (PSSC) recommendations to reform the controversial Security Offences (Special Measures) Act 2012 (Sosma), warning that the law remains vulnerable to abuse.

Human rights lawyer Andrew Khoo said a major overhaul of Sosma is long overdue due to inade­quate safeguards against misuse.

He agreed with the PSSC’s findings, stressing the need for stron­ger judicial oversight.

“There needs to be closer and stricter supervision by the courts, which must take firm action against any attempt to ignore or circumvent legal protections,” he said.

Khoo said Sosma’s scope is overly broad and often applied to offences that do not constitute genuine threats to national security.

“The interpretative threshold used by law enforcement is extre­mely low, with almost any offence argued to be a threat to national security. The PSSC has highlighted specific cases demonstrating this problem,” he said in an interview on the committee’s recommendations.

'CLICK TO ENLARGE'
'CLICK TO ENLARGE'

The PSSC made eight recommendations in its Human Rights, Election and Institutional Reform 2025 report, proposing amendments to Sosma, including a review of the 28-day detention period.

The report also noted that since Sosma came into force in 2012, there has been no proposal by deputy public prosecutors to use electronic monitoring devices (EMD), even in cases involving individuals with mental health issues.

On the use of EMDs, Khoo said such measures should be limited to individuals who pose the most serious threats to national security and present a genuine flight risk.

“The use of an EMD is a serious infringement of human rights, including the right to life and freedom of movement, and should only be justified in the rarest circumstances,” he said, adding that the devices are costly to maintain despite allowing limi­ted freedom of movement.

Meanwhile, lawyer Datuk N. Sivananthan also called for the swift implementation of the PSSC’s recommendations, describing Sosma as an ongoing problem affecting not only detainees but also their families.

“Sosma is increasingly used to facilitate arrests and remands without the justifications required under normal remand procedu­res. The potential for abuse is rampant,” he said.

Sivananthan singled out Section 30 of Sosma, calling for its complete repeal as it allows continued detention even after an accused has been acquitted, pending the final disposal of the prosecution’s appeal in the Federal Court.

“This effectively means someone could succeed at every stage of the trial process and still be detained for up to five years. This provision is unique to Sosma,” he said.

Sivananthan added that in prac­tice, the law allows the police to detain individuals for prolon­ged periods regardless of trial or appeal outcomes, with no effective recourse available.

He also noted that Sosma is being invoked even when other specific laws are available to address the alleged offences.

“Authorities have realised that by using Sosma, there is almost no judicial supervision.

“Any assertion made is often accepted without question.

“In contrast, other preventive laws have stronger checks and balances,” he said.

Sivananthan urged the government to reintroduce judicial discretion at all stages of the process, particularly in matters of remand and bail.

“The courts should be empowe­red to dismiss cases where it is clear that the law is being misused,” he said.

On the continued non-use of EMDs, Sivananthan attributed the issue to a lack of functioning devices and an effective monitoring system, adding that bail provisions should be amended to allow courts to consider EMDs in exceptional cases.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!

Next In Nation

Police tracking two vehicles linked to alleged cable theft attempt
We will take back Dusun Tua from Umno in GE16, says Selangor DAP
MCA Youth not looking for trouble but will not shy away from confrontation, says Ling
Nearly two-thirds of Malaysians have no emergency savings, says Fadillah
RM90mil allocation for non-Muslim religious bodies, schools in Sabah
Dr Wee calls on 'Barisan warriors' to unite and regain Putrajaya
DAP open to khemah besar but let’s discuss first, says Loke
Home Minister says yet to receive info on police report over Negri MB's alleged resignation letter
PM and I have yet to meet, says Loke on resignation
Loke warns DAP against complacency, absent leaders to be blacklisted

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read