Dissenting judge: No requirement to confirm royal addendum


PUTRAJAYA: There is no legal duty on the respondents named by Datuk Seri Najib Razak in his legal bid to confirm the existence of a royal addendum order that would allow him to go on house arrest, says a Court of Appeal judge.

Justice Azizah Nawawi, who chaired a three-judge panel of the appellate court, said this in her dissenting judgment in Najib’s appeal against the High Court’s dismissal of his leave application to initiate a judicial review here yesterday.

On the main appeal, Justice Azizah said she found no appealable error by the High Court judge.

“I agree with the finding of the High Court judge that there is no legal duty imposed on the respondents, particularly the Pardons Board, to confirm the existence or produce any order related to the exercise of the power of pardon,” she said.

“There is no provision in the written law or the very Constitution that could make the Pardons Board confirm or disclose any existence of a pardon order, including the addendum order.

“The appellant failed to demonstrate that such a legal duty existed to confirm or produce the same.

“I am of the considered opinion that there is no merit in the appeal. It must be dismissed with no cost,” she said.

The court had also heard Najib’s application to adduce new evidence in his application.

The new evidence was a letter from the Pahang Sultanate Council stating that the Sultan of Pahang had indeed given the order for Najib to serve the remainder of his jail sentence under house arrest.

The letter, dated Jan 4, was addressed to Najib’s eldest son Datuk Mohamad Nizar Najib and signed off by Datuk Ahmad Khirrizal Ab Rahman, who is the Comptroller of the Royal Household of the Sultan of Pahang.

On this application, Justice Azizah said Mohamad Nizar himself affirmed in his supporting affidavit that he frequently met with the Sultan of Pahang in his line of work.

“In view of the admission that he met the Sultan frequently, it cannot be said that fresh evidence could not be obtained with reasonable diligence for use before the hearing before the learned High Court judge.

“This can be seen when the deponent (Mohamad Nizar) subsequently obtained the same addendum many months later after the decision by the learned High Court judge.

“Therefore, I am of the considered opinion that there is no merit to the application on this fresh evidence,” Justice Azizah added.

The 2-1 majority decision, which was held by two other judges – Justices Azhahari Kamal Ramli and Mohd Firuz Jaffril – had overturned the High Court’s dismissal of Najib’s leave application and allowed his application to admit the letter from the Pahang Sultanate Council into evidence.

Follow us on our official WhatsApp channel for breaking news alerts and key updates!
Najib Razak , royal addendum , court

Next In Nation

Anwar extends 68th birthday wishes to Sultan Ibrahim
Two women killed after being thrown from car on Federal Highway
Police track down driver of yellow car in Hulu Langat hit-and-run
Search underway for woman swept away at Ipoh waterfall
MCA will not be complacent after winning 12 seats in three recent state polls, says Dr Wee
Ampang Hospital ER hit by 25% surge in patients, causing delays in ward admissions
Floods: Number of evacuees in Perak, S'gor drops, Negri fully recovers
Elopura rep calls for security audit after military aircraft alleged used in attempt to smuggle drugs into Sabah
Govt must ensure cultural heritage of all communities gets equal protection, says MCA Youth chief
MyEVOC urges stricter enforcement of EV charger regulations, transparency in fire investigations

Air Pollutant Index

Note: API is calculated based on 24hr running average of the most dominant parameter.

Highest API Readings

    Select State and Location to view the latest API reading

    Others Also Read