PETALING JAYA: While the extensive mid-term review of the 12 Malaysia Plan (12MP) is a welcome move, a think tank is concerned over the additional RM15bil for development expenditure.
In a statement Thursday (Sept 14), the Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs (Ideas) said that the increase would have some implications on Malaysia’s debt burden.
"There is an urgent need for policies and incentives used in the 12MP to be revisited and improed upon to overcome challenges arising from meeting the given targets by 2025," Ideas CEO Dr Tricia Yeoh said in the statement.
Ideas also called on the government to focus on providing sound forecasting and estimations in the upcoming budget to support its 12MP targets.
The full text of the statement can be read below:
12MP: Additional RM15bil in development expenditure has implications on Malaysia’s debt burden
The Institute for Democracy and Economic Affairs (Ideas) welcomes the extensive mid-term review which shows that, overall, the current administration continues the plan’s focus on the key issues of poverty eradication, narrowing the inequality gap, attracting FDIs, and transparency in fiscal spending.
Nevertheless, Dr Tricia Yeoh, CEO of Ideas highlighted that based on the review, “As a country aspiring to be a high income country in the next 5 years, we are off the mark.
"To date, median monthly wages are recorded to be at RM2250, while the target set is RM2900 per month by 2025.
"The share of wages today is only 32% of GDP, still below the mark of 40%.
"Hence, there is an urgent need for policies and incentives used in the 12MP to be revisited and improved upon, to overcome the challenges arising from meeting the given targets by 2025.”
More importantly, Ideas is concerned over the plan to add an additional RM15bil to the development expenditure, which will be translated to at least RM90bil planned expenditure annually.
While the increase is positive, historically the government has not had the capacity to fully utilise the allocated expenditure.
Budget documents suggest that the government only managed to spend around 91% of the estimated development expenditure from 2011-2021, except in 2018 where the government spent more than the estimates.
The increase would have some implications on Malaysia’s debt burden.
While the Economic Affairs Minister states that Malaysia would still maintain a fiscal deficit target of 3.5% by 2025 despite the increase, such a statement should be backed by mid-term expenditure and revenue forecasts.
Malaysia’s development expenditures have been almost fully financed by loans, as more than 97% of the revenue goes to operating expenditure.
To achieve 12MP’s fiscal targets, there is an even greater need to expedite the move towards targeted subsidies as expected in Budget 2024 to generate the required savings.
Ideas calls on the government to focus on providing sound forecasting and estimations in the upcoming budget to support its 12MP targets.
This is where the promised Fiscal Responsibility Act (FRA) can establish a legal requirement for more detailed reporting, and for fiscal policy to be backed by data-driven rather than populist justifications.
Ideas will release another statement once the debates conclude next week, where we will provide more comprehensive feedback on the overall mid-term review of the 12MP.
