PGSM: Federal Court ruling will open the floodgates

KUALA LUMPUR: The Federal Court ruling on the unconstitutionality of the Selangor state law provision which punishes unnatural sex will open the floodgates for other parties to challenge other provisions under the states’ syariah criminal enactment, says the Malaysian Syariah Lawyers Association (PGSM).

Its president Musa Awang said the apex court ruling would effectively dampen a state to legislate its own syariah criminal offences despite the offences being within the precepts of Islam, as the ruling now considers syariah criminal offences, if there exists similar provisions in the Federal laws, to be repetitive and void.

“The court’s decision has significant implications for state legislatures in the country, particularly syariah criminal offences, ” he said in a statement.

Musa also said the ruling would “close the door” on the proposal for hudud and qisas to be enacted in the country as hudud offences such as stealing (sariqah), robbery (hirabah) and qisas offences such as murder (al-qatl) are also contained under the Penal Code.

He urged the state government and other authorities to take a drastic and holistic decision to revisit and review the existing syariah criminal laws to ensure the syariah laws would not be challenged by other parties in the future.

Meanwhile, former Court of Appeal judge Datuk Seri Mohd Hishamudin Md Yunus applauded the ruling.

“The judgment is in line with the basic constitutional principle that state legislation cannot contravene the Federal’s, ” he said in a statement.

The commissioner with the Human rights Commision (Suhakam) said under the Federal List of the Constitution, the creation of a criminal offence was within the legislative competence of Parliament and not a state legislature’s.

“Accordingly, for the prohibition against ‘unnatural sex’, it is already provided for by Parliament under Federal law, namely, Section 377A of the Penal Code. That being the case, a state legislature, such as the Legislative Assembly of the State of Selangor, cannot legally enact a similar offence. And to do so would be a contravention of the Federal Constitution, ” he said.

Article type: free
User access status:

Next In Nation

Hishammuddin: Rohingya issue should be dealt properly to avoid further influx of refugees
Covid-19: SJK(C) Yuk Chai among 19 schools ordered to close in Petaling district
Agong congratulates two M'sian students for excelling in ACCA
Sabah's first sugar factory, aquaculture project to create 1,000 direct job opportunities
Rail sector will need talent pool of at least 100,000 for new approved projects, says Dr Wee
Fresh from contraband seizure, Melaka cops vow to step up anti-crime efforts during Ramadan
Almost 146,000 migrants without papers take up offer to go home or work legally
M'sian and his Viet lover nabbed on suspicion of drug trafficking
Covid-19: 589 new cases, three deaths and four clusters linked to 13 longhouses recorded in Sarawak
Covid-19 vaccination sign-ups still very low in Pahang, says MB

Stories You'll Enjoy