Judicial leave application for Malaysians on Singapore death row dismissed


  • Nation
  • Friday, 24 Mar 2017

KUALA LUMPUR:  The applications for leave for a judicial review by two Malaysians who are on death row in Singapore for drug trafficking have been dismissed by the High Court here.

S. Prabagaran, 30, and factory worker K. Datchinamurthy, 32, and their mothers filed the leave applications to compel the Government to refer Singapore to an international court claiming that they were denied fair trial.

Justice Hanipah Farikullah struck out the applications by Prabagaran and his mother V. Eswary, 54, and also Datchinamurthy and his mother A. Letchumi in chambers on Thursday.

Met by reporters later, counsel N. Surendran said Justice Hanipah dismissed their applications on grounds that the matter was related to foreign policy and the court has no jurisdiction to interfere.

Surendran said Prabagaran and Datchinamurthy and their mothers wanted to obtain an order for the Government to refer the island republic to International Court of Justice (ICJ) saying that they were denied fair trial.

He said their applications to refer the issue had been struck out by the court and the court made no order as to cost as the matter was public interest.

"We will definitely appeal as we think the decision is wrong.

"This is regarding the treatment of our citizens abroad. So our view is that the court could interfere and issue the necessary order," he said.

Prabagaran and Eswary are applying to the High Court in Malaysia to compel the Government here to take his case to ICJ.

They have named the Malaysian Government and its Foreign Affairs Minister as respondents.

Among others, they are seeking a declaration that the respondents are legally obliged to protect and give effect to Prabagaran’s right to a fair trial and life and liberty.

In her affidavit, Eswary said that her son was convicted in the Singapore High Court on July 22, 2014, for trafficking in 22.24g of diamorphine.

She said he was sentenced to death on Sept 22 that year under the Misuse of Drugs Act.

Eswary said her son’s appeal to the Singapore Court of Appeal was dismissed on Oct 2, 2015.

She said Prabagaran then applied to the Court of Appeal to re-open his appeal and set aside his death sentence but this was dismissed on Dec 2 last year.

Eswary said she submitted a memorandum to the Malaysian High Commission in Singapore to refer the case to the ICJ on Dec 21 last year but there had been no response.

Meanwhile, Datchinamurthy and his mother Letchumi are seeking a declaration from the Malaysian Government and its Foreign Ministry that they are legally obliged to protect and give Datchinamurthy a right to a fair trial and/or right to life and liberty.  

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
   

Did you find this article insightful?

Yes
No

Next In Nation

‘Govt going in the right direction’
Rakyat feel optimistic with recovery
More fires raging at forest reserve
Six open burning cases being probed, says minister
Cradle Fund CEO murder trial: Arrow fragments found in house compound, court told
Inter-district travel opens up opportunities for tourism sector, says Nancy
Umno members must vote to cut ties with Bersatu, says Ku Li
Covid-19: Sabah records lowest daily cases at 53 since last September
Covid-19: Seven new clusters detected, one linked to Seremban old folks home, others to workplaces
CMCO: Travel between Selangor, KL allowed but police permission needed to enter Putrajaya, says Ismail Sabri

Stories You'll Enjoy


Vouchers