High Court judge’s directive wrong, says Chia’s counsel

  • Nation
  • Wednesday, 22 Jun 2005

PUTRAJAYA: A High Court judge was wrong in ordering a lower court to admit the testimony of five witnesses taken in a Hong Kong magistrate’s court pertaining to the trial of Tan Sri Eric Chia Eng Hock, the Court of Appeal heard yesterday. 

Chia’s counsel Datuk Muhammad Shafee Abdullah said the High Court, in exercising its revisionary powers, had in fact allowed a “back door” appeal when in law, interim appeals governing such matters were not sanctioned. 

“Where there is a situation where appeal is an avenue, revision should not be used as a back door,” he said. 

Muhammad Shafee said that even though the judge had used his “paternal supervisory powers,” it must be exercised in the clearest of cases in which the lower court acted without power or passed a sentence out of its range, for instance. 

“It must be so obvious a mistake that the judge can call for the record. Corroborative to that, nobody has a right to submit,” he said. 

On April 29, the High Court in exercising its revisionary powers, had overturned a Sessions Court's decision to reject the prosecution’s application to produce the evidence from Hong Kong in Chia’s CBT trial. 

Chia, 72, is appealing against this High Court decision. 

He is charged with misappropriating RM76.4mil from Perwaja Rolling Mill and Development Sdn Bhd on Feb 19, 1994. 

Chia also faces an alternative charge of dishonestly disposing of the company’s funds. 

The trial before Sessions Court judge Akhtar Tahir continues on Aug 10. 

The appeal before Court of Appeal judges Justices Dennis Ong, Abdul Aziz Muhammad and Azmel Maamor continues today.  

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3

Next In Nation

Covid-19: Another Malaysian linked to casino dealer cluster in Singapore
Three arrested at illegal online gambling centre in KL
Yan, Kedah gazetted as a federal port
Remand extended for nine suspects held over dead teen girl
Cops thwart suspected rapist's attempts to escape from hospital
Cops: Investigation into possible MCO violations by Neelofa and family underway
Ain Husniza to attend online programme for global youths
AstraZeneca to be offered to eligible Sarawakians on first-come, first-served basis
AstraZeneca round 2: Good to vaccinate senior citizens but faster rollout overall needed, say Malaysians
Penang to implement outreach programmes at nursing homes

Stories You'll Enjoy