Morningstar estimates that requirement may affect more than 1,600 funds and lead to stock divestments of as much as US$40bil. — Bloomberg
COPENHAGEN: New rules limiting how freely asset managers can attach the environmental, social and governance (ESG) label to funds sold in Europe promise to trigger a widespread purge across the industry, according to a fresh analysis by Morningstar Sustainalytics.
Roughly 4,300 funds domiciled in the European Union (EU) that currently claim to pursue ESG goals, or that carry similar sustainability-related labels, are potentially affected by new guidelines unveiled in May by the European Securities and Markets Authority (Esma), Morningstar Sustainalytics said on Wednesday.
“While it’s impossible to predict the full impact of these guidelines, we expect their implications to be significant,” Hortense Bioy, head of sustainable investing research at Morningstar Sustainalytics, said in an emailed statement. “They have the potential to completely reshape the ESG fund landscape in Europe.”
Esma said last month that investment funds with ESG labels or equivalent terms will need to have at least 80% of their assets under management in something that’s actually related to the fund’s name.
Funds also can’t invest in companies that are on an exclusion list under the EU’s Paris-aligned benchmark rules.
Morningstar estimates that requirement may affect more than 1,600 funds and lead to stock divestments of as much as US$40bil, if asset managers decide to adjust their portfolios in order to keep their current labels.
Esma began work on its naming requirements in 2022, after a boom in ESG investing led to concerns that some product claims were misleading.
A year earlier, the EU had enforced its Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation, an investing rulebook under which some US$13 trillion of assets are now registered. According to Bloomberg Intelligence, roughly 60% of those are currently listed as either promoting ESG or making it an outright objective.
The sectors that are most vulnerable to divestment as a result of Esma’s new rules include energy, industrials such as railroads and defence, and basic materials, Morningstar said.
The countries whose companies are most exposed are the United States, France and China, in terms of market value, according to the researcher.
Morningstar identified TotalEnergies SE, Tencent Holdings Ltd, Ecolab Inc and Shell Plc as some of the stocks that are most likely to see divestment pressure, due to the EU’s ESG fund-naming rules.
“At best, only 56% of funds with the specific term ‘sustainable’ in their names would be able to keep the term if the minimum threshold for a ‘meaningful’ allocation to sustainable investments is set at 30%,” Morningstar said.
“The remaining 44% of funds would need to increase their allocation to sustainable investments, tweak their sustainable investment methodology, or rebrand.” — Bloomberg
