Custody battles: IGP's welfare home option

  • Nation
  • Wednesday, 11 Jun 2014

KOTA KINABALU: Inspector-General of Police Tan Sri Khalid Abu Bakar has suggested that the children involved in recent custody battles between Muslim and non-Muslim parents be placed under the care of the Welfare Department until the courts sort out the issues.

“The cases involve two legal systems, the Syariah and the civil. We do not want to be tersepit ditengah (caught in the middle),” he told reporters after meeting senior Sabah police officers and district police officers in the Eastern Sabah Security Zone (Esszone).

Reiterating his stand that the police would not enforce orders from both Syariah and civil courts, the IGP said that as both laws were equal, it would be unfair to choose one over the other.

He said the basic facts in the cases of Muslim convert Izwan Abdullah against his ex-wife S. Deepa in Negri Sembilan and kindergarten teacher M. Indira Gandhi against her former husband Mohd Ridzuan Abdullah in Perak were similar, adding that in both cases, the men had converted without the knowledge of their wives, resulting in women claiming custody of their children.

“I will discuss this with the Perak and Negri Sembilan police chiefs and see whether it is best for the children to be kept in the care of the Welfare Department.

“This way, the parents need not fight over the custody of their children and can visit them at the homes if they want to,” he said.

In April 2009, Mohd Ridzuan, formerly known as K. Patmanathan, took away his youngest child Prasana Diksa, then 11 months old, and converted her and her two siblings Tevi Darsiny, then 12, and Karan Dinish, then 11, to Islam without Indira’s knowledge.

The High Court later granted Indira full custody of all three children and on March 11, 2010, Mohd Ridzuan was ordered to return Prasana Diksa to the mother.

The Syariah High Court, meanwhile, also awarded Mohd Ridzuan custody of all three children.

In the case involving clerk Deepa and her Muslim convert husband Izwan who was previously known as N. Viran, both the Syariah and civil courts have granted them custody of the children.

In December last year, Deepa filed an application to get back her children, Sharmila, nine, and Mithran, six, who had also been converted to Islam and to quash the custody order by the Syariah Court.

On April 11, the IGP had said that the police would not act against Izwan for taking his son from his ex-wife’s house, despite a High Court order granting Deepa custody of their two children on the grounds that there were two clashing court orders on the matter.

In May, the Appeals Court rejected Izwan’s request for a stay of the Seremban High Court’s decision to grant custody of the children to Deepa.

Mohd Ridzuan has so far defied a court order to return Prasana Diksa while Izwan too has failed to return Mithran as ordered by the court.

Related stories:

Focus on executing court rulings, Heng tells police

Syarie lawyer suggests mediation in Prasana case

Indira: Cops must arrest ex-husband

Couple give opposing reaction

CJ: Procedures in place to parties caught in custody battle

Mums can cite cops for not taking action

Grandma worried over status of grandkids

Police should leave it to the courts, says former judge

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Subscribe now to our Premium Plan for an ad-free and unlimited reading experience!

Family & Community , Islam


Next In Nation

Budget 2023: Large allocation for infrastructure, education must continue for Sabah, S'wak
Budget 2023: Semporna's island residents want water woes resolved
MACC concerned by rise in number of women nabbed for corruption, says Azam
Covid-19: M'sia detects 1,360 new cases, total now at 4,843,865
Malaysia ready to offer aviation training opportunities to Senegal, says Dr Wee
Many against holding GE15 during monsoon season, claims Selangor MB
Economic challenges, floods in focus as Parliament resumes
JKR closes part of Bagan Lalang road after sinkhole appears
INTERACTIVE: With GE15 imminent, here are all the laws passed by Malaysia’s 14th Parliament so far
The International 2022: Huge prize pool, top teams, and three M'sian players to watch

Others Also Read