Appeals Court declares organiser can't be punished

  • Nation
  • Saturday, 26 Apr 2014

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal here has declared that an organiser of a public gathering cannot be punished for not giving a 10-day notice before the event.

Justice Mohamad Ariff Md Yusof ruled in a landmark judgment that Section 9(5) of the Peaceful Assembly Act (PAA) 2012 – which calls for a fine of up to RM10,000 for those who fail to give notice – was unconstitutional.

“That which is fundamentally lawful cannot be criminalised,” he said, referring to the right to assemble peacefully enshrined within Article 10 of the Federal Constitution.

The panel unanimously allowed the appeal by former PKR strategic director Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad to have Sections 9(5) of the PAA to be declared unconstitutional and quashed the charge against him.

“Thus the charge and prosecution is invalid and set aside. The applicant (Nik Nazmi) is also acquitted and discharged,” ordered Justice Ariff.

The other two judges on the panel – Justices Mah Weng Kwai and Hamid Sultan Abu Backer – also read out their own judgments, which spanned almost two hours.

Justice Mah noted that the restriction placed by Section 9(1) – which required a 10-day notice be given – was a disproportionate restriction.

He said there were existing provisions under the Penal Code to charge those attending the assemblies, should they become unruly.

Justice Hamid Sultan found that the 10-day notice requirement was not ultra vires Article 10(2) of the Federal Constitution, saying it was the organiser’s social responsibility to inform the police to ensure the assembly participants’ safety.

The written judgments are expected to be made available on Monday, said Justice Ariff.

Nik Nazmi, who is Seri Setia assemblyman, was charged under Section 9 (1) of the PAA on May 17, 2013 for his failure to notify the police 10 days prior to the Black 505 rally at the Kelana Jaya Stadium on May 8.

However, Shah Alam High Court had on Nov 1, dismissed his application to strike out the charge stating that the 10-day notice period under PAA was not unconstitutional.

Article type: metered
User Type: anonymous web
User Status:
Campaign ID: 1
Cxense type: free
User access status: 3
Subscribe now to our Premium Plan for an ad-free and unlimited reading experience!

Next In Nation

Three senators propose discussion of LCS issue in Dewan Negara
No tax defaulters among expats in Malaysia, says Immigration DG
Form RCI to investigate littoral combat ship fiasco, urges Umno Youth
Water tank bursts in Ketereh school, several students injured
Cops seize drugs worth over RM1mil, six arrested in KL
Second successive symposium on industrial tree plantation in Sabah
Overseas travel will be easier soon with relaxed Covid-19 restrictions, says Dr Wee
Johor cops arrest man for crashing into seven cars under influence of alcohol
Peter Anthony acquitted of money laundering, CBT charges
Bring those responsible for LCS scandal to justice, says Sik MP

Others Also Read