Columnists

One Man's Meat

Saturday, 27 May 2017

A clash that wasn’t, a peace that isn’t

This picture taken on May 20, 2017 shows members of a hardline Indonesian Muslim group holding wooden sticks during a local tribal festival in Pontianak, West Kalimantan province, as anti-riot police and military personnel keep watch. About 90 percent of Indonesia's 255 million people are Muslim, with most practising a moderate form of Islam. The country is also home to substantial minorities of Christians, Hindus and Buddhists. / AFP PHOTO

This picture taken on May 20, 2017 shows members of a hardline Indonesian Muslim group holding wooden sticks during a local tribal festival in Pontianak, West Kalimantan province, as anti-riot police and military personnel keep watch. About 90 percent of Indonesia's 255 million people are Muslim, with most practising a moderate form of Islam. The country is also home to substantial minorities of Christians, Hindus and Buddhists. / AFP PHOTO

Tension was high in Indonesias West Kalimantan last weekend,  and although police were able to contain the situation, the problem remain. 

LAST Saturday, the video clips – real and fake – emerging from Pontianak in West Kalimantan, Indonesia were disturbing.

Saturday was the start of the one-week Gawai Dayak Harvest Festival – an annual festival with many Dayak men and women clad in their traditional costumes, carrying their spears and machetes.

The Dayaks were doing their annual parade on Gajah Mada Street – the main street in the provincial capital on the Indonesian side of Borneo.

Nearby, Islamic Defenders Front (FPI) and Persatuan Orang Melayu (POM, which is a satellite group of FPI in West Kalimantan) organised a rally in a mosque.

They demanded that the police charge West Kalimantan governor Cornelis for insulting the ulama.

Their slogan was #BelaUlama (Defend Ulamas), a reference to some Dayak groups rejecting top FPI leaders from Jakarta visiting Pontianak.

According to Indonesian Andreas Harsono of Human Rights Watch, some of those in the opposing groups almost clashed on Gajah Mada Street.

“A video showed many young Malay men with their sticks running toward the Dayak group from the Flamboyant market.

“But the police quickly set up a line to separate them,” he said to me via WhatsApp.

“Police also used anti-riot trucks, water cannons and thousands of personnel. On the other side of the street, near the KFC restaurant, a video also showed many young Dayak men rushing to the meeting point.”

On Saturday, Harsono shared these videos via WhatsApp. It was chilling. The first thing that I thought was mangkuk merah terbang (a bowl of wine with a drop of blood in it to invoke the spirit of a warrior).

In Kalimantan in 2001, my colleague P. K. Katharason covered the ethnic violence in which indigenous Dayaks forced Madurese transmigrants from Borneo back to Java.

He told me that the Dayak warriors took a sip of wine with a drop of blood before their bloody clash with the Madurese, some of whom were beheaded.

Some of the viral video clips that emerged from Pontianak on that day were fake (the events had happened, but not on that day). The situation was tense but there were no clashes.

“Why is there religious tension in Pontianak?” I asked Harsono.

“The tension is here to stay. POM basically argued that police should charge Cornelis with blasphemy. They argued insulting ulama equals insulting Islam,” he said.

“It’s obviously a shallow argument, but Cornelis also reported POM to the police for showing hatred. Many Dayak militias back Cornelis. The Dayak also aired many anti-FPI statements.”

It is, said Harsono, still potentially a problem – a big problem, if the underlying issue is not resolved.

The FPI was one of the main players in getting Jakarta governor Ahok, the Hakka nickname of Basuki Tjahaja Purnama, jailed for blasphemy. The next target is Cornelis.

“What are the similarities and differences between Ahok and Cornelis?” I asked Harsono.

Both Ahok and Cornelis are Christians. Both of them are governors in two of Indonesia’s 34 provinces. Both provinces are pluralistic areas with many ethnic and religious groups. Ahok is an ethnic Chinese. Cornelis is ethnic Dayak.

“Cornelis is a long time PDI-P (founded by former Indonesian President Megawati Sukarnoputri) member. He also chairs the Dayak Customary Council. It’s a powerful ethnic group with many militias,” he said.

“Ahok is a maverick, a politician who often moved – from PIB, a small party, to Suharto’s Golkar to Prabowo’s Gerinda to Megawati’s PDIP in less than two decades. It means that he did not build deeper political support. Ahok also does not have an ethnic backup.”

Harsono said Cornelis himself has a thuggish background.

“He’s a traditional power player in Indonesia’s murky political scene.

“Ahok is just a plain business professional who wanted to do good, joining a small political party in his home regency Belitung Timur, later becoming its regent,” he said.

Kalimantan has a history of violence.

“There were three huge outbreaks of violence targeting ethnic minority Madurese in post-Suharto Kalimantan.

“First, in 1997, there was the killing of around 600 ethnic Madurese in Sanggau Ledo area. The perpetrators were mostly Dayak militias.

“Then there was 1999, with the killing of around 3,000 Madurese in Malay-dominated Sambas area.

“After that, in 2001, Dayak militias beheaded between 1,000 and 3,000 Madurese settlers in Sampit,” said Harsono.

“None of the masterminds of these mass killings were brought to justice. The Government also has not investigated this communal violence which took place in chaotic post-Suharto Indonesia. But those killings, involving Dayak and Malay militias, emboldened those two ethnic groups, galvanising ethnic politics in Kalimantan,” Harsono said.

Many Madurese victims, he said, are also still looking for the graves of their loved ones.

“At least 4,500 Madurese people were killed. I estimated, when doing my research on these mass killings, at least 120,000 Madurese left Kalimantan due to the killings,” he said.

It means, said the Human Rights Watch researcher, that the roots of this violence are still deeply entrenched in Kalimantan.

“Many of those involved in the killings, from spreading hate speeches to actual beheading, from those involved in propaganda to those involved in the production of weapons, are still living with impunity in Kalimantan,” he said.

Sabahans and Sarawakians were closely watching what was happening in Kalimantan last Saturday.

They see it as somewhat similar to what’s happening in Sabah and Sarawak, in a much milder form and minus the bloody violence.

For example, the Kadazandusun community was alarmed to see photographs of a “Kaamatan Islamik” event organised by Muslim movement Hidayah Centre Foundation.

Viral photographs promoting the event showed several women dressed in long, loose robe-like variations of the traditional Kadazandusun black-and-gold costume, but with their arms and heads covered.

Huguan Siou (the para­mount Kadazandusun leader) Tan Sri Joseph Pairin Kitingan issued a statement, saying that religion should be kept out of Kaamatan (the Harvest Festival) as it is a cultural festival and not a religious one.

Tags / Keywords: Opinion , Philip Golingai , One Man s Meat

More Articles

Filter by

This picture taken on May 20, 2017 shows members of a hardline Indonesian Muslim group holding wooden sticks during a local tribal festival in Pontianak, West Kalimantan province, as anti-riot police and military personnel keep watch. About 90 percent of Indonesia's 255 million people are Muslim, with most practising a moderate form of Islam. The country is also home to substantial minorities of Christians, Hindus and Buddhists. / AFP PHOTO

A clash that wasn’t, a peace that isn’t

27 May 2017

Tension was high in Indonesias West Kalimantan last weekend, and although police were able to contain the situation, the problem remain.

The leader of the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI), Habib Rizieq (right).

Is FPI’s Rizieq Shihab a threat?

20 May 2017

Should Malaysians be worried that the controversial Indonesian cleric appears to have spent time here recently?

Jakarta governor-elect Anis Baswedan (R) and his deputy governor-elect Sandiaga Una (L) hold hands during a press conference. - AFPpic

It’s all about the voters’ needs

13 May 2017

A campaigner explains why Ahok did well in 2012 but failed in the recent gubernatorial election.

Jakarta's Governor Basuki Tjahaja Purnama (2L), also known as "Ahok" looks on at a press conference. - Filepic

Tiptoeing through election minefields

6 May 2017

Jakarta’s recent gubernatorial polls were difficult to navigate, for both politicians and pollsters.

Police patrol at Semporna waters.

A wild frontier town defender

29 April 2017

A Shafie loyalist explains that the former Minister had to balance development within his own Semporna constituency with his duties at the national level.

A wild frontier town divided

22 April 2017

As Semporna struggles with an influx of undocumented foreigners, a filthy environment and a lack of infrastructure, it has also become a political battleground.

Terrorist meets an expected end

15 April 2017

The death of Abu Rami, the Abu Sayyaf leader, came as no surprise to those who knew him and the life he led.

Elizabeth (left) and Esther Koh, daughters of missing pastor Raymond Koh.

Faith upheld by support, empathy

8 April 2017

It’s been over 50 days, but the family of Pastor Raymond Koh continues to pray for his return.

Chong (right) speaking at a press conference for Lim. - HAZIM FAUZI/The Star

Beware that moment of weakness

1 April 2017

IT started with a “hi” and if I had been naive, it would have ended with me naked and eventually bankrupt.

Muhammad Ali versus George Foreman in Kinshasa on October 30, 1974. - AFP/Filepic

Watch out for the rope-a-dope tactic

25 March 2017

Sabah’s opposition Parti Warisan Sabah should avoid over-confidence because Umno still has some tricks up its sleeve.

  • Page 1 of 3

Go to page:

advertisement

Recent Posts

advertisement