Watching The World

Published: Sunday May 24, 2015 MYT 12:00:00 AM
Updated: Sunday May 24, 2015 MYT 7:37:05 AM

Perpetual battle for Papua

Despite strong hopes for liberalisation under President Jokowi, the people of West Papua are fighting an uphill battle.

OF late, I’ve been coaching my son as he prepares for the IGCSE history exams, and we have been revisiting many fascinating phases of history.

While the impact of some phases of history is no longer that relevant, it’s clear that many nation-states in the 21st century are still feeling the after effects of the colonial era. I guess the very fact that I’m an ethnic Indian writing this article in English and living in Kuala Lumpur can be traced back to the British colonisation of both India and Malaya.

Colonisation took place in many forms, I’d say. Even the spread of a religion can be colonisation. What better way to get a local population to submit to foreign rule than to get them to accept your God? With it, natives accept the language and customs of the purveyor of the new religion until their own identity has been buried in the rapture of following a new deity.

In practical terms, it’s a conquest without a war. South African Bishop Desmond Tutu summed it up as such: “When the missionaries came to Africa, they had the Bible and we had the land. They said ‘Let us pray.’ We closed our eyes. When we opened them we had the Bible and they had the land.”

Aside from the collusion of religion and colonial authorities, one can’t help noticing how modern conflicts have been shaped by the whims and fancies of administrators. For example, the Nigerian Civil War (also known as the Biafra conflict) basically erupted as a power struggle between the Yoruba, Hausa-Fulani and Igbo, three large tribal groupings which found themselves in the same country because all had been administered by the British. And lest we forget, the formation of Malaysia has its roots in uniting British territories across the South China Sea.

One of the more unfortunate scenarios involves the state of West Papua in Indonesia. At the time of independence, Indonesia’s president Sukarno welded the various islands that had been under Dutch rule into a unified nation. While Sumatra, Kalimantan, Bali, Sulawesi and the rest had both commonalities and differences with the dominant Javan island, West Papua (known then to the Indonesians as Irian Jaya) was practically a different world.

Sharing a massive island with the independent nation of Papua New Guinea, West Papua was incorporated into Indonesia as a province after a dubious vote was taken in 1969. Culturally, its people are from aboriginal tribes, with genetic links to the various peoples of the South Pacific, not the rest of Indonesia.

West Papua, which has abundant natural resources, has the misfortune of having a small population. Opponents of West Papua’s absorption into Indonesia believed that the natives have just traded one colonial master for another.

Three years ago, I did a lengthy article with a colleague about West Papua. This was soon after the killing of independence leader Mako Tabuni. When the liberal President Joko Widodo assumed office in October 2014, there was hope that he might finally overturn the dismal human rights situation that was alleged by groups working in West Papua.

I say alleged because access to West Papua has been strictly controlled for all these years. Journalists have had to apply to the Indonesian government even to enter. While places like Aceh and Timor L’este (which even got independence) have experienced an opening-up, West Papua is still a vast dense mystery.

In the last two weeks there have been some truly positive signs from Jokowi. In conjunction with his visit to Papua, his office has clarified that foreign journalists are now free to visit the region. More importantly he released five men widely believed to have been political detainees, who were jailed after a raid on a weapons depot in 2003.

Yet just on Thursday, reports of the Indonesian military rounding up peaceful Papuan protesters in the capital of Jayapura were being circulated. The protesters, mildy emboldened by Jokowi’s visit, are asking for West Papua to become a full member of a regional Melanesian group. Are we experiencing “one-step forward, two-steps back” again?

At a time when human rights violations around Asean are making global headlines, maybe it’s time to look at a dire situation that had gone under the radar for many decades. I truly hope that the tide will turn for the people of West Papua.

> The views expressed are entirely the writer’s own.

Tags / Keywords: colonisation

More Articles

Filter by

Tribal rally: A file picture of West Papuan youths protesting outside Indonesia’s parliament.

Perpetual battle for Papua

24 May 2015

Despite strong hopes for liberalisation under President Jokowi, the people of West Papua are fighting an uphill battle.

Bracing for un-Finnished business

26 April 2015

For all the stark and icy beauty, the progressive education and the erudite citizens, it seems that Finland is set for tough times. Fortunately there can scarcely be a group of people better suited to withstand the cold.

Paradise once more

12 April 2015

A troubled nation needs to seize the chance to rise above its bloody past.

Opposition figure: Jeyaretnam with his second son Phillip.

That other great Singaporean

29 March 2015

As the world flocks to honour Lee Kuan Yew, let’s spare a thought for his former sparring partner Joshua Jeyaretnam.

Active campaign: Netanyahu delivering a speech to his supporters during an election campaign meeting in the Israeli Mediterranean coastal city of Netanya. — AFP

Benji will be back

15 March 2015

We can expect a familiar face to emerge triumphant in Israel’s next election.

No way Jose

1 March 2015

Former Portuguese Prime Minister Jose Socrates is fighting a losing battle for his personal freedom.

A man holds a placard while gathering for a vigil for three young Muslims killed in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, at Dupont Circle on February 12, 2015 in Washington, DC. The three were killed by a neighbor in what police said was a dispute over parking and possibly a hate crime. AFP PHOTO/MANDEL NGAN

Atheists and the new terror

15 February 2015

The way in which Western media covered the triple shooting in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, has raised disputes among local observers.

Greece is the word

1 February 2015

For a number of disparate reasons, Greece, much like the proverbial Georgia, is on my mind.

The victims: Displaced people from Baga listening to President Goodluck Jonathan in a Maiduguri camp. Thousands are feared to have been killed in what could be the group’s deadliest attack, according to human rights groups. — AFP

Time to banish Boko

18 January 2015

AS some of the world mourns and questions itself over the killings at the French satirical magazine that need not be named, Boko Haram has upped the ante in Nigeria.

Charting our own course

4 January 2015

ANOTHER year has rolled in inexorably, and we have to stop and ask ourselves what direction we are headed towards. I am part of a generation that grew up under the inspiring Vision 2020 slogan but it seems that as the date draws nearer, that particular dream is one we talk less and less about.


Recent Posts