X Close


Published: Tuesday June 24, 2014 MYT 12:00:00 AM
Updated: Tuesday June 24, 2014 MYT 11:58:17 AM

Bar Council: Court should have granted leave

PETALING JAYA: The Federal Court should have granted leave to Catholic weekly Herald to hear its appeal in the ongoing dispute with the Home Ministry to use the word “Allah”, the Bar Council said.

In a statement yesterday to The Star, Malaysian Bar vice-president Steven Thiru said the questions posed by Herald met the requirements laid down under Section 96(b) of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964, which allows an appeal to the Federal Court if it was “on the effect of any provision of the Federal Constitution”.

“The court only had to decide whether the questions posed met the requirements of Section 96(a) or (b) of the Courts of Judicature Act 1964.

“The Federal Court is not required to go into the merits of the intended appeal at this stage. The questions met the requirements of Section 96(a) and, at any event, the constitutional questions posed by the applicant should have been allowed under Section 96(b),” said Steven.

He added that with the denial of leave, the 2013 decision of the Court of Appeal stands.

“It can be interpreted as being applicable to other publications and not just Herald, and it is regrettable that the Federal Court has refused leave,” said Steven.

MCA president Datuk Seri Liow Tiong Lai said he was very disappointed with the Federal Court’s decision.

“We will continue to provide the necessary assistance to solve the issue,’’ he said.

Related stories:

Catholic Church may file a review against decision
Apex court says no to church
CFM: Christians will continue using term 'Allah'
Malaysians need time to accept, says Mufti

Tags / Keywords: Courts & Crime, Herald's appeal rejected, Federal Court


  1. Weightlifter Mohd Hafifi wins Malaysia's first gold medal at Commonwealth Games
  2. MH17: First crash victim identified, says Netherlands
  3. Najib heading to Netherlands to ensure third part of deal is honoured
  4. Massive toll rate hike for Causeway users from Aug 1, including Singapore-bound vehicles
  5. Betong blast: Two Malaysians among 36 injured
  6. Balik kampung traffic: Congestion along all major highways (Updated at 3pm)
  7. Baby dies after being flung out of car in accident
  8. Last plane bearing call number touches down at KLIA
  9. RM400 one-way pass to go home
  10. Kindergarten teacher given leave to take top cop to court