Home > News > Nation
Thursday July 18, 2013 MYT 3:53:00 PM
Friday July 19, 2013 MYT 10:29:50 AM
Alvin Tan being escorted by the police at the Sessions Court. He and Vivian Lee were charged over their facebook posting and pornographic pictures in their blogs. - Bernama pic
KUALA LUMPUR: Sex bloggers Alvin Tan and Vivian Lee claimed trial in the Sessions Court here Thursday to three charges related to their Ramadan bak kut teh greeting on their Facebook page and pornographic pictures in their blogs.
The charges against Alvin Tan Jye Yee, 25, and Vivian Lee May Ling, 24, were read before judge Murtazadi Amran.
In the first charge, they were jointly accused of making a seditious posting on their Facebook page by uploading a photo of themselves eating bak kut teh (a pork dish) with the greeting Selamat Berbuka Puasa with bak kut teh (fragrant, delicious and appetising) together with the halal logo.
They allegedly committed the offence at 10.48pm between July 11 and 12 at 568-14-18, Kompleks Mutiara Jalan Ipoh, Mile 3 1/2 here.
They were charged under subsection 4 (1) (c) of the Sedition Act 1948, which is punishable under subsection 4 (1) of the same Act and read together with Section 34 of the Code Penal.
For the first offence, they face a fine up to RM5,000, an imprisonment up to three years or both, and imprisonment up to five years for subsequent offence.
Judge Murtazadi denied bail for both accused after taking public interest into account.
He said the court was not affected by external elements in deciding on the bail.
Earlier, Deputy Public Prosecutor Noorin Badaruddin asked the court not to grant bail to the accused as the charges under Section 298A (1) (a) of the Penal Code and the Film Censorship Act were non-bailable offences.
"Of course, we accept the court discretion to allow bail on the two charges, but the prosecution objected to any bail granted until the trial is over," he said.
Noorin said secondly, both accused had a tendency to upload pictures that could arouse public outrage.
The lawyer representing both accused applied for bail for both of them on the ground that the charges had yet to be proven and was premature in nature.
Chong Joo Tian said the prosecution could not pre-empt that the accused had a tendency to commit similar offences as they had yet to be found guilty.
"Both my clients gave full cooperation to the MCMC (Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission) and the police during investigations and they do not have any criminal record and the offence they were accused of do not involve any form of violence," he said.
Deputy public prosecutor Ishak Mohd Yusoff argued that the court should take the surrounding circumstances into account in determining whether bail could be granted.
"Alvin Tan is a household name and if we were to 'Google' only the name Alvin, pictures and articles about him will pop up, for which, if it is not controlled, it can destroy the society and religion. No doubt it does not involve violence, but it is a serious offence," he said.
Noorin asked for the three cases to be tried together under Section 170 of the Criminal Procedure Code as they entailed the same transaction and witnesses.
However, Chong asked for the second charge to be tried separately as the first and third charges involved posting pornographic pictures on different websites.
Noorin said Section 170 allowed criminal offences to be tried together even though all the three cases were different and the prosecution would prove the offences occurred in the same transaction.
Murtazadi allowed the three cases to be tried together and set Aug 23 for mention.
He also gave an opportunity to the two accused to state their reasons why bail should be granted to them.
Tan said, "I want a bail. I do not have any power, position, wealth, employment or job. And all my multimedia items have been confiscated by the MCMC which would affect my tendency to upload photos and access the Internet."
Lee, who is a kindergarten teacher, said: "I would also like to be given bail and I have the same opinion as Alvin."
Tan is being held at the Sungai Buloh Prison and Lee at the Kajang Prison. - Bernama
Tags / Keywords:
Sex bloggers, Alvin Tan, Vivian Lee, Bak Kut Teh
Copyright © 1995-2013 Star Publications (M) Bhd (Co No 10894-D)