X Close


Published: Thursday April 12, 2012 MYT 12:00:00 AM
Updated: Sunday May 26, 2013 MYT 12:49:36 AM

10 fail in bid to challenge Lynas licence (updated)

KUALA LUMPUR: Ten local residents have failed to get leave to challenge the Atomic Energy Licensing Board's decision to grant a temporary operating licence for Lynas Malaysia's rare earth procession plant in Gebeng, Kuantan.

High Court judge Justice Rohana Yusuf agreed with the objections raised by the Attorney-General's Chambers against the leave application that the residents should have appealed to the minister over the Lynas plant.

She said it has been disclosed to her that there are five other persons appealing on the same decision to minister and that it must be given due deference.

"In my considered view, the appeal process that is taking place had to be given effect because it is process provided by the statute. It is a more suitable and appropriate forum to discuss matters highly technical in nature," she said.

She said if the court were to proceed with its reviewing power over the decision it would render the appeal "superfluous" and meaningless.

On Feb 17, the group of 10 residents had filed the application, naming the Atomic Energy Licensing Board (AELB), which oversees the production, application and use of atomic energy and radioactive material, the Director-General of Environment Quality and Lynas Malaysia Sdn Bhd (Lynas) as respondents.

The AELB had raised preliminary objections over the leave application.

In the application, the residents sought a certiorari order to quash the AELB's Jan 30 decision to issue the temporary licence to Lynas Malaysia.

They also applied for an order to prohibit the AELB from issuing any temporary or permanent licence to Lynas, except or until the company presented a detailed evaluation report on the plant's effects on the environment to the Director-General of Environment Quality, and until the report was approved.

More in The Star on Friday.

Related Stories: Court to decide on Lynas' TOL on April 12

Tags / Keywords: Nation, News


  1. Malaysian passport 9th best in the world
  2. Japanese oil tanker robbed, three crew believed kidnapped in dramatic dawn raid
  3. KL set to be in 'security lockdown'
  4. 'Godfather' believed to have killed 13-year-old boy
  5. Every kind of success in life depends on our virtues as a person
  6. Brave boy comforts family
  7. College staff turn to loan sharks after salaries unpaid for four months
  8. God saved me from serious harm, says boy
  9. Selangor MB Khalid: Can't stop water rationing yet, but will review next week
  10. Guan Eng: Heads will roll if Penang water rationing imposed